Andy Shauf – Darker Days – CD Review
Andy Shauf
Darker Days
P is For Panda
6/10
Andy Shauf is a mystery man. There are few traces of the singer-songwriter on the Net, and the folk musician isn’t exactly known for giving interviews. Yet the Canadian has garnered his own, small following with his blend of folk and hard rock. Now he’s poured all that introspection into a new album Darker Days, a mix of acoustic and electric guitar, and a few samples for fair measure. However the record ultimately proves to be derivative and underwhelming.
The two highlights of the album (at least in my opinion), “The Greatest Moments” and “Were You In Love With Me,” are bookends of happiness and gloom. The former, an up tempo ditty about romantic love, and the latter, a song of dejection full of distorted guitars and vaunted F chords worthy of the Smashing Pumpkins, show that Shauf has heart. Yet in many respects they are the exception to the rule, and to get to them listeners must endure a sea of sleepers that have more in common with poetry written by six graders than the nuanced lyrics of a troubadour. That doesn’t mean that every song on the record is bad. Just most of them.
In defense of Shauf, it is his first album, and he does score points here and there (the grungy guitar chords and sampling of road traffic on “Gone” would never be attempted by contemporaries such as John Mayer). Yet unlike Mayer, he faces the danger of being left behind in the thicket of similar artists like him. The fact that he has a silky smooth voice- like Mayer- doesn’t help him too well either. Neither does the fact that he tries too hard to emulate some of his more famous peers. It’s hard enough being talented without being compared to someone else.
Hopefully, this isn’t the last we’ve heard from him- emphasis on the word “hopefully”. The guy can carry a note, and unlike most “musicians” he can actually play an instrument. In four years time he might be worth paying attention to. But not Darker Days, not by a long shot.
If you’re looking for something to fill your CD collection by all means buy it. Otherwise, pass it up.
–John Winn
Are you serious? I was googling Andy Shauf because I saw him perform and was blown away at his incredible songs for such a young guy. How can you even consider yourself a credible review if you both mis-spell the artist name and give the wrong title? This is blatantly amateurish. Your writing would likely receive similarly harsh criticisms to this review.
I highly doubt John would consider himself a credible review. I like how the guy who misspells “misspells” is giving us editing tips. No, really, I appreciate it. I edited it because you were totally right on the name part. My bad. John also didn’t review the live act, he reviewed the album. Apples and oranges, Stevie.
-The Emperor.
While I don’t entirely agree with Stevie, I do find this review slightly confusing and not especially helpful. In my mind, a 6/10 is a decent record, not one full of “mostly” bad songs that are completely derivative. Also, what’s up with that off-handed “unlike most ‘musicians’ he can play an instrument” comment?
Sorry to be picky, but I’m not getting it. I should admit I’m a little biased as I do like the album, though I’ll agree it’s certainly not amazing.
Chris,
You have to understand, in the world of Racket, a 6 is like par for course. The songs were in key, the recording was done in a studio versus a closet and the lyrics were understandable.
As for the “musicians” crack, I can’t tell you how many albums we get where you can immediately tell that the “musician” has no idea how to actually play their instrument more than chopping up and regurgitating the shit they learned in high school.
I’m glad that you and Stevie posted that you like it. Healthy debate is awesome, amirite?
-The Emperor.
Haha, fair enough. I can easily relate to the chore of wading through the sea of crappy albums to get to the good stuff.
Thanks for being good sports. I agree, healthy debate is nice because it means people are paying attention and if nobody takes themselves too seriously, it’s fun.
I was out and about looking for reviews about this guy because I just covered him on my blog and wanted to know the general consensus.
Leave your response!
Categories
Recent Posts
Authors
Recent Comments
Most Popular
RacketMag on Twitter
Most Viewed